At Brewster's New Buffalo, the menu offers a delightful array of dishes designed to satisfy a variety of tastes, from classic comfort foods to exciting specialty pies. The Sourdough Pies are a standout, featuring options like the savory "Pizza Time," zesty "Betty White," and the crowd-pleasing "New Yorker" with its perfect balance of flavors. If you're in the mood for something with a bit more flair, the Thin Crust Special Pies are a must-try. The "Bianco" is a creamy white pizza with a rich, garlicky finish, while the "Cali Pie" delivers a fresh, vegetable-packed punch. For mushroom lovers, the "Fungi" Marg Pie brings together the earthy taste of mushrooms with gooey melted cheese, and the "Quattro Formaggi" pie is a cheese lover’s dream come true.
If you're looking for something heartier, Brewster's Lunch Classics have you covered. The Bolognese is a rich, meat sauce that pairs perfectly with a house salad or comforting soup. The Cacio E Pepe features a creamy, peppery sauce that coats the pasta beautifully, while the Chicken Alfredo delivers a creamy and indulgent dish, topped with juicy grilled chicken.
For those who prefer sandwiches, there are several enticing options like the Smoked Turkey Sandwich and the crispy Chicken Schnitzel Sandwich. And for the burger enthusiasts, the Double Smashburger is a juicy, flavorful treat that’s bound to satisfy your cravings.
Don’t forget to indulge in the tempting Starters such as Bruschetta with fresh tomatoes or the warm, cheesy Spinach + Artichoke Dip. For a sweet ending, the Hummingbird Cake or a slice of Tiramisu makes for the perfect conclusion to any meal.
Whether you're stopping by for a casual lunch or a cozy dinner, Brewster’s New Buffalo offers an impressive variety that guarantees there’s something for everyone.