Brewster's New Buffalo
If you're ever in New Buffalo, Michigan, and craving a delicious, casual meal with great vibes, Brewster's New Buffalo is the spot to be. Located at 11 W Merchant St, this charming restaurant offers a welcoming atmosphere that's perfect for groups, families, and anyone in the mood for a relaxed dining experience. Whether you’re dining indoors or enjoying the outdoor seating, Brewster's strikes the right balance of moderate noise and a laid-back vibe, making it an ideal place to unwind and enjoy good company.
Brewster's New Buffalo is known for its mouthwatering selection of dishes that will make your taste buds dance. If you’re a fan of Italian classics, you can’t go wrong with their Cacio E Pepe or a comforting plate of Chicken Alfredo. For something fresh and hearty, the Rustic Steak Salad is a fantastic choice, packed with flavor and perfect for a light but satisfying meal. If you’re in the mood for a family favorite, their Spaghetti and Meatballs will hit the spot every time. And for dessert? Treat yourself to their rich and zesty Italian Lemon Cream Cake – the perfect sweet ending to a delicious meal.
What makes Brewster's stand out is not just the food but the atmosphere. The restaurant's casual setting makes it ideal for groups or a night out with the kids, and it’s easy to see why it's a local favorite. Whether you're looking to celebrate a special occasion or simply enjoy a good meal, Brewster's New Buffalo has everything you need for a memorable dining experience.
From the delicious menu to the comfortable setting, Brewster’s truly caters to everyone, making it a must-visit when in the area.
Reviews
Amanda was a fantastic server. The cocktails were exactly what we were looking for. The presentation of the food was more than we were anticipating and tasted great! Hats off to the chef responsible for the desserts- between the two of us, we ordered 3 haha. We're looking forward to returning.
The spaghetti here is so good. The pasta is cooked perfectly, and the sauce is rich and flavorful. Every bite is comforting and satisfying, and I love how well the flavors come together. Definitely a dish I would order again.
The service was great, the food was delicious and didn't break my bank account, but I hate when they nail you for a "convenience fee".... I would rather leave that for the server. Also, a woman at the next table was enjoying a birthday lunch with her boyfriend. I asked two different waiters if they could bring her something for her birthday, a piece of cake, a cupcake, a cookie. Crickets. If they had done those things, it would've been a five and they would've knocked it out of the park.
Nice atmosphere, friendly service. Our waiter split our bill between our party which was appreciated. Make sure to make a reservation on open table as this is a busy area. We had dinner at 9pm on a Saturday with a reservation. We didn't end up getting seated until 9:20 because it was so busy. Bread is available if you request it. Only the first round is free. We had bruschetta as an appetizer (6 pieces). There was the perfect amount of toppings and the right size bread to go with it. I would order this again! It was so tasty! I had chicken Alfredo for my dinner. The portion sizes on the pasta is ginormous. It is easily two meals. I liked the sauce and the pasta. The chicken in it was just average. The pizza that people ordered looked delicious as well as the desserts. My entire table really enjoyed their meals. We would come back!
My family's favorite restaurant. Food and service is always amazing!!! Dinner for 2 is a great deal, and their dishes are fantastic. Don't sleep on this place. It's one of the best around.